The Muddy Waters of American Christianity
I am thankful to live in America. I really am. The blessings here are countless. If you are a traveler or a reader, you, too, know just how blessed we are here in this country. There is a reason so many want to come here.
But there are a few downsides to this country, as well. Perhaps the most important being the muddy, undefined Christianity that is found here.
I have been thinking about that some over the past years but it was made so much clearer to me when I recently read the testimony of a Hindu from a foreign land.
What does new life with Christ look like in America? It’s a quick prayer and then, for so many, a return back to the sin and worldliness that was characterizing their lives before a prayer. No change, no freedom, no victory, no love. Instead, there is a wrong assumption regarding God’s grace and this keeps them imprisoned in sin and worldliness.
Contrast this to this line from the testimony of a former Hindu:
I had begun to understand that being “born again” really involved—through Christ’s death and resurrection for me—the death of my old self and the resurrection of a new person.
No option for both to exist together. The old man has died and a new man is alive (Colossians 3).
It’s not about just a sentence prayer spoken to Almighty God. If the words spoken yield no transformation from an old man to a new man then it’s just a sentence.
Living among heathens or pagans, the difference in the believer vs those around them is like night and day. The new believer in a heathen land recognizes that the two religious systems are diametrically opposed to one another. It’s very obvious.
Here in muddy, religious America that is harder to see. Everyone loves Christ. Everyone points to Jesus. Everyone claims He is their Savior.
Well, not everyone, of course. But, rather strangely, it has become the “popular” thing to do.
And this muddies the waters considerably. Jesus tells us to expect to be hated by the world. He says that the world will persecute us. (John 15:18-20)
The temptation is to believe that America is just different. Yes, Christians are persecuted in other lands, but not here. This is a wonderful Christian nation.
I think it’s important we ask ourselves if that’s really true. Is the Christianity represented here in America what we read about in the Bible?
Does the Bible teach that we can continue on in our sin, claiming God’s grace over it all? Does the Bible teach that living a sinful lifestyle without any conviction represents genuine faith? Does the Bible teach that we can love the world and partake of all of its philosophies, entertainment, styles, pastimes, etc. in our new lives?
And if it does teach this, is the Christianity of America actually genuine Christianity?
Look, I am not judging individuals here. We can never do that. There are too many factors, too many unique journeys. We can’t know and that’s not our place.
What I want to do today is to encourage you to step back and look at the movement of Christianity as a whole here in this country (if you live here) or wherever you live. Does it represent biblical Christianity?
Or is it a comfortable Christianity that allows for our fleshly desires and cares more about feelings and emotions than about what God’s Word says?
The Hindu that was miraculously saved removed the false gods and idols from his house immediately. He realized right away that this was something he had to do.
What about our false gods before Christ? Do we remove them from their place when we come to Christ? Do we even think about it when we get saved? Do we even think about it after we are saved? The idols that are so “accepted” in these muddy religious waters… things like sports, popularity, careers, family, money, etc.
I know I am preaching to the choir. Most of you reading this are not unfamiliar with this dynamic as I’ve talked about it often. But this testimony of the Hindu really made it much clearer than it’s been to me for a long time.
The real Jesus Christ makes a different in lives or He doesn’t. And we can’t have it both ways.
If Jesus makes a difference then those that are genuinely saved will be different; Christ’s power will transform them from their old self to their new self—slowly or quickly matters not—there will be a change.
And if Jesus doesn’t make a difference and people just go on to live in the chains of sin and the prison of worldliness, then what good even is Christianity and of what value the Bible?
It is so very easy to find ourselves going down downstream with the crowd. It’s takes no thought. And it doesn’t invite criticism.
However, as believers, we are called to swim upstream. We are called to live by the truth of God’s Word and to examine every single thing through its lens.
Just because someone uses the names of God and Jesus does not mean they are genuine. Just because our favorite athlete points to the sky and gives credit to God does not mean he is saved. Just because an author or preacher says something that sounds biblical does not mean they are biblical.
Let’s keep our eyes open and pray for discernment as we navigate these muddy American Christian waters.











